2026-06-11, 09:13 PM
I'm setting up a new machine I'm wondering about giving read and write access, I'm guessing if I want things like fan artwork/themerr then I will need to give it read/write access?
|
2026-06-11, 09:13 PM
I'm setting up a new machine I'm wondering about giving read and write access, I'm guessing if I want things like fan artwork/themerr then I will need to give it read/write access?
2026-06-11, 10:59 PM
That is a question that could go either way. If you have Jellyfin set to write to the folder the media is in to add artwork, trickplay, and whatever else next to the files then yes. If you don't then no it would use the metadata folder Jellyfin is assigned to use.
However, since you are talking about "Plugins" that could also be a yes or no regardless of what Jellyfin is set to. Since in theory a plugin isn't exactly limited to what Jellyfin operates within. It can have it's own settings and own requirements. I don't use to many plugins myself, and the ones I do have never went to crazy, but technically it could or could not need write access for something based on how it's coded.
2026-06-12, 06:06 AM
(This post was last modified: 2026-06-12, 06:13 AM by Bladefin. Edited 2 times in total.)
(2026-06-11, 10:59 PM)EliteAlien Wrote: That is a question that could go either way. If you have Jellyfin set to write to the folder the media is in to add artwork, trickplay, and whatever else next to the files then yes. If you don't then no it would use the metadata folder Jellyfin is assigned to use. I don't have trick play added to the media folders or any artwork as I want Jellyfin to be as fast as possible,but I have noticed that if I want themerr to work then I have to let Jellyfin have write access. While I like the idea of having theme music I don't won't to compromise the system.
2026-06-12, 07:29 AM
(2026-06-12, 06:06 AM)Bladefin Wrote: I don't have trick play added to the media folders or any artwork as I want Jellyfin to be as fast as possible,but I have noticed that if I want themerr to work then I have to let Jellyfin have write access.I was just using those as an example, because some plugins piggyback off Jellyfin while others do not and have advanced settings. It all depends on the plugin as these are not generally made by the Jellyfin team members and third-parties not related to them. Which is also why adding repositories that are not in the Jellyfin list by default gives you a warning. Likely a plugin will not break anything or do anything majorly bad, but there always is that one time, so you get the warning nonetheless. That being said, if Themerr requires it, then you would have to talk with the makers of that plugin. Potentially within their Github and make a feature request of sorts. As for theme music plugins. Well I know of two others that exist or existed. I always use to use this one "https://github.com/danieladov/jellyfin-plugin-themesongs". Yet, I don't know if it can or could write elsewhere. As I always had write access to my files. (2026-06-12, 06:06 AM)Bladefin Wrote: While I like the idea of having theme music I don't won't to compromise the system.Compromise to what exactly? In what way? If you mean from outside your network, then if someone gets into your Jellyfin and it has a network attachment, well you've already been compromised be it write or not. If someone gets inside your network they can literally map everything that is connected via a simple command. Listing all your local IP's of devices and unless you're using massively different accounts, passwords, and maybe OS's. Well if there is a software vulnerability in one thing of the OS packages it's likely in the others as well. Like say if "sudo" had a bug and it granted root access through brute forcing and you had multiple Linux machines. If Windows Linux-Subsystem-For-Windows or whatever or even the remote-access bugs that can happen or have happened. If someone is that determined to break into your network, they will find a way. (Not saying security isn't important, but that a Samba share is most likely not the attack vector.) If you mean you don't want deletion of files to that share. Then make an admin account that is the only one that can modify the server. Then make that account not able to be remotely logged into. You can do this inside the profile. So no one outside your network can use this account if not on your local network. If you mean a plugin destroying for files. Well I don't install thousands of them and honestly I only have around six that don't come with Jellyfin's basic repositories. None of which have destroyed my files, even with writing files. Not saying it couldn't happen, but I've never seen this behavior for all the years of me using Jellyfin. It could be possible if you started using the file modification plugins or whatever? I don't know, but honestly, to many plugins in general I think equals a bad time in Jellyfin. It increases a chance of something going wrong as you could have plugins that could even conflict with one another for all you know.
2026-06-13, 10:48 AM
(This post was last modified: 2026-06-13, 10:49 AM by Bladefin. Edited 1 time in total.)
(2026-06-12, 07:29 AM)EliteAlien Wrote:(2026-06-12, 06:06 AM)Bladefin Wrote: I don't have trick play added to the media folders or any artwork as I want Jellyfin to be as fast as possible,but I have noticed that if I want themerr to work then I have to let Jellyfin have write access.I was just using those as an example, because some plugins piggyback off Jellyfin while others do not and have advanced settings. It all depends on the plugin as these are not generally made by the Jellyfin team members and third-parties not related to them. Which is also why adding repositories that are not in the Jellyfin list by default gives you a warning. Likely a plugin will not break anything or do anything majorly bad, but there always is that one time, so you get the warning nonetheless. It was mainly the concern that a plugin my go weird and delete my media, I don't share my connection to the internet,just local network. I have had Jellyfin for a couple of years but I'm only now wanting to usie JF with all the bells and whistles, as I now have a better system to have the Jellyfin server on. So I'm just getting to see what plugins are best while keeping it all safe.
2026-06-13, 11:09 AM
(2026-06-13, 10:48 AM)Bladefin Wrote: It was mainly the concern that a plugin my go weird and delete my media, I don't share my connection to the internet,just local network.The only plugins I know that delete media are the ones meant to scan and remove them or remove them based on watch progression. I've never used them, and never had a plugin delete anything, but there is a first time for anything I am sure. Yet, I would say if the plugin doesn't have a good bit of stars and closed reports on Github. Then It's not worth even downloading as it's not something to trust. As no one has vetted it for the stars and no closed issues means no one is possibly using it to even make something as simple as a feature request. So that would be maybe a little advice about plugins and possibly why I don't have issues like that... Maybe? (2026-06-13, 10:48 AM)Bladefin Wrote: I have had Jellyfin for a couple of years but I'm only now wanting to usie JF with all the bells and whistles, as I now have a better system to have the Jellyfin server on.Jellyfin plugins in my opinion are kind of limited. While there are a lot of them, a good handful are basically the same thing but with a different creator. Some categories have basically the same plugin listed multiple times, but it's not the same plugin. Sort of like the Theme song downloader, lol. That being said there are a few good ones. Yet, if you really want something good for Jellyfin, I find the best things are companion style applications that run in there own Docker container and just connect with Jellyfin. That or plug Jellyfin into Kodi and use Kodi plugins to itch the scratch of what is lacking for Jellyfin. That way you sort of have a little of both. Depending on what you use. (2026-06-13, 10:48 AM)Bladefin Wrote: So I'm just getting to see what plugins are best while keeping it all safe.People tend to go here first. https://github.com/awesome-jellyfin/awesome-jellyfin That being said, there are projects on there that have no issues and no stars. Just because it's listed on a list like this, doesn't mean it's vetted. So what is hidden in the code could bite your whole network not just a share. Probably not, but there are @$***** people out there trying to mess with others like that, so never know. Nonetheless, have fun with it, and maybe keep track of each plugin one at a time. That way if anything goes wrong you kind of vetted it and can single out a problem easier.
1
|
|
|
|
|