Can't play multiple versions of movie on v10.10.3

[alleycat]

I've had some movies setup to play multiple versions of the same movie since v10.9.11, which I could had sworn was working correctly. Now in v10.10.3 I can't play the other versions just "defaults" to the 2160p version. I can click on the 1080p version but when I hit the play button in the same screen it starts playing the 2160p version. Any ideas?

[theguymadmax]

Did you change the filenames since upgrading?

[alleycat]

Did you change the filenames since upgrading?

No, but I could have added the 720p after the rest... Like I was stating, have three other movies configured like this and they all do the same.