4k vs 1080p playback

[hillyarb]

I just got myself a 4k disc ripper for Christmas. So I was finally able to get a digital copy of my Super Mario Brothers 4K + Bluray combo. I ripped the 1080p version a while ago, both with makemkv, I then used handbrake to convert to mp4 files. On the 4k file I just increased the max resolution to 4k but everything is the same. The results are pulled from my 1440p monitor, but I am getting similar looking results on my LG oled in the living room, with the same reason for transcoding. What is going on here? Is it a file issue or a client issue or a setting in Jellyfin or something else? I have made sure things are up to date, and rebooted the server. Thanks! 
Also tried to add a screen shot, can't get it to upload. 4k is washed out compared to 1080p. 

4k:
Playback Info
Player: Html Video Player
Play method: Transcoding
Protocol: https
Stream type: HLS

Video Info
Player dimensions: 2560x1291
Video resolution: 3840x1608
Dropped frames: 10
Corrupted frames: 0

Transcoding Info
Video codec: H264
Audio codec: AAC (direct)
Audio channels: 2
Bitrate: 14.9 Mbps
Transcoding progress: 1.3%
Transcoding framerate: 26 fps
Reason for transcoding: The video's range type is not supported

Original Media Info
Container: mov
Size: 10 GiB
Bitrate: 15.4 Mbps
Video codec: H264 High
Video bitrate: 14.8 Mbps
Video range type: HDR10
Audio codec: AAC LC
Audio bitrate: 160 kbps
Audio channels: 2
Audio sample rate: 48000 Hz

1080p: 
Playback Info
Player: Html Video Player
Play method: Direct playing
Protocol: http
Stream type: Video
Video Info
Player dimensions: 2560x1291
Video resolution: 1920x804
Dropped frames:0
Corrupted frames: 0
Original Media Info
Container: mp4
Size: 4.1 GiB
Bitrate: 6.3 Mbps
Video codec: H264 High
Video bitrate: 5.6 Mbps
Video range type: SDR
Audio codec: AAC LC
Audio bitrate: 160 kbps
Audio channels: 2
Audio sample rate: 48000 Hz